People's Democracy

(Weekly Organ of the Communist Party of India (Marxist)


Vol. XXXVII

No. 29

July 21, 2013

 

 

 

In Defence of the ICDS

Six Lakh Anganwadi Employees Observe Black Day

 

A R Sindhu

 

ON July 10, 2013, nearly six lakh anganwadi workers and helpers observed ‘Black Day’ at the call of the All India Federation of Anganwadi Workers and Helpers (AIFAWH). More than two lakh anganwadi workers and helpers came out on the streets wearing black dress, carrying black flags, banners etc, against the move to privatise the services of ICDS in the ‘ICDS Mission’, demanding the implementation of the recommendations of the 45th Indian Labour Conference for recognition as workers, minimum wage and pension and freedom of association. They held rallies, demonstrations and dharna at district headquarters. In many states, in spite of the heavy downpour, they came with black umbrellas with the demands written on them.   Many had blackened the face and burned the effigy of the minister for women and child development, Krishna Tirath for her double-talk and anti-worker policies.

 

AGAINST PRIVATISATION

OF ICDS

The alarming levels of child malnutrition in India have been in the headlines for quite  a long time, but much more recently, with so many studies coming out, some with ‘alternative strategies’ to address it, many have a very different purpose. Releasing one such study, less than a year ago, the prime minister himself has said that the alarming levels of child malnutrition in India, which is home to half of the malnourished children in the world, is “a national shame” and so “we must think beyond ICDS” to address it.

 

The Integrated Child Development Services (ICDS) Scheme is the biggest of its kind in the world and is unique in providing various services for the overall development of children under six years. It covers 7.5 crore children and 1.7 core pregnant and lactating mothers providing supplementary nutrition, pre-school education, healthcare and referral services. The NDA and UPA governments were trying to privatise this scheme as per World Bank directives, trying to introduce ready-to-eat food, handing over to NGOs etc., but could not be successful due to the resistance by the unions and the people.

 

Now in a revised attempt, the UPA-2 government, with the active involvement of the World Bank (which is running a ‘ICDS Project IV’ since 2007, and has recently provided a loan to the government of India for the ‘revised implementation framework for ICDS’) has brought out a route map for privatisation of ICDS. ‘The ICDS Mission’ for ‘strengthening and restructuring of ICDS’ declared in November 2012, at the dictates of the World Bank, is aiming for the total privatisation of the services and siphoning off the public money into the private hands.

 

DETRIMENTAL

PROPOSALS

Why a Mission: A ‘Mission’ itself is a short term programme for a limited target which will be wound up after achieving the ‘Mission’ targets. The services provided by the ICDS are not ones which can be stopped once any goal is achieved. The nutritional care and pre-school education provided to the majority of the 0-6 age group children of our nation, in the anganwadi centres should be a continuous service and must continue as a permanent service like schools and hospitals. The spirit of the Supreme Court order to universalise the ICDS is to make it a permanent scheme.

 

Change in focus: In the ICDS Mission, the focus will be shifted from the supplementary nutrition to ‘Information, Education and Communication (IEC).

 

Inadequate allocation for infrastructure: The recent CAG report on ICDS had shown the poor infrastructure of the ICDS, many anganwadi centres without building, drinking water facilities etc. In the Mission, the proposals for infrastructure development, including building anganwadi centres, providing facilities in centres etc, the allocation is only for 15 percent of the centres.

 

In the name of community participation, workers are asked to collect materials from the community for the anganwadi centre. This is reported from Himachal Pradesh and Gujarat. So it will be easy to bring in the PPP model, as proposed in many states.

 

Mandatory privatisation: In the ‘Mission’, the government makes it mandatory to hand over a minimum of 10 percent of the centres to NGOs and another 10 percent to panchayati raj institutions. The entire running of a sector/project of ICDS, including the appointment and monitoring, must be handed over to the NGOs. Not only that, to make them take up the anganwadi centres, the NGOs must be given the ‘flexibility’ to spend the money according to their priority and will! Provisions are made to hand over the supply of supplementary nutrition also to NGOs, in the name of ‘community participation’.

 

Role of the Corporate NGOs: Many NGOs like ISKCON and Naandi Foundation, who started supply for ICDS and Mid Day Meal Scheme a few years back, have made assets worth hundreds of crores by now. The corporate houses, in the name of corporate social responsibility, are bound to spend two percent of their profit for social causes. They float their own NGOs, get government fund for running schemes such as ICDS, simultaneously show their money also going into the NGO’s account, complete the responsibility, also get tax concessions and other benefits in the name of ‘social cause’, get foreign fund as well for feeding ‘India’s hungry children’! Thus the UPA government helps the corporates to implement ‘apna paisa, apne haath’!( your money in your hands)! Many of these corporate NGOs have the bureaucrats, politicians or wives of bureaucrats and politicians on their director boards. The recent scam in Maharashtra, with more than 1000 crore rupees of ICDS given to fake NGOs, exposes how this ‘model’ enables the loot of public money.

 

Apart from this, it is helping the corporates to gain public sympathy and support, which may help to reduce protests they have to face in their moves to appropriate public and natural resources. The Vedanta company is running anganwadi centres in Odisha and Chhattisgarh, in the mining areas, and according to some media stories, the adivasis in the ‘Niyamgiri’ feels that such a good company which feeds our children cannot do anything bad! Thus, this can help to minimise the protest from the local tribal population in acquiring forest land for mining.

 

Nutrition business: The move to introduce ready-to-eat food in the centres in place of the freshly cooked locally available food, had started at the time of UPA-1, at the initiative of the global NGO, GAIN, which has the directors of food giants like Cargil on its board of directors. But it could not be successful due to the resistance by the trade unions and nutritional experts. The move is so strong even now that many such NGOs are still ‘working hard to solve India’s nutrition problem’! One must recall the scam in UP where the supply of the supplementary nutrition of ICDS is done by the liquor baron Pondi Chada’s company for a contract of more than  rupees ten thousand crores.

 

Privatise pre-school education: In the name of strengthening the pre-school component and Early Childhood Care and Education (ECCE), the ICDS Mission has provisions to allocate the ICDS funds to the existing private pre-primary schools! It is directed that the financial allocations be made to the existing private nursery schools with of course ‘flexibility’ in norms of spending. In a policy regime where education has become a profit making industry, where corporate houses own most of the new generation educational institutions including the nursery schools, this is a direct move to siphon off public money to the corporate accounts. This must be fought tooth and nail.

 

Poor working conditions of the employees: Although the Mission has increased the working hours and the stipulated work of the anganwadi workers and helpers, -the timing of the anganwadi centres is increased to six hours and more, five percent centres to be converted into anganwadi-cum crèches. But there is no increase in the remuneration of the workers and helpers.

 

Now provision is made for all the workers and helpers above 65 years to be retired. But there is no mention of any retirement benefits for them.

 

Apart from this, in the ‘Mission’, all the new appointments will be on contract basis. There is a proposal for a link worker whose payment will be on incentives based on outputs.

 

The AIFAWH is determined to fight the government’s move to dismantle the ICDS, fight the efforts for converting it from a service to the poor to a profit making industry, as it has done with the health and education sectors, but through the back door.

 

RECOMMENDATIONS

OF THE 45th ILC

Adding insult to the injury, in the recently held 45th Indian Labour Conference, where the working conditions of the workers working in various government schemes, including the anganwadi workers and helpers were discussed, the ministry of women and child development opposed the proposals of the ILC for their recognition as workers, not volunteers, for paying them minimum wages and social security including pension.

 

Krishna Tirath, WCD minister who recently appeared in news headlines for declaring a proposal for “recognising the women’s housework by paying salary to housewives”, when it came to the turn of recognising the women’s unpaid labour in these government schemes, in a most shameful manner opposed the ILC recommendations of recognising the valuable services of its own employees, who subsidise the government by nearly 27,000 crore rupees per year.

 

Despite the repeated demand by the federations of anganwadi workers of the central trade unions, the government is neither ready to discuss with the unions the changes it is proposing to make in the scheme; nor has it taken into account the opinions of the organisations of beneficiaries like that of women, peasants and agricultural workers. Instead, in the name of discussion with the ‘stake holders’, the government is holding discussion with NGOs and agencies like CARE and USAID.

 

WIDE

CAMPAIGN

The  AIFAWH working committee in its meeting held in March 2013, thoroughly discussed the ICDS Mission documents and the experiences in the implementation in various states and decided to take up nationwide campaign and struggles against the moves to dismantle the ICDS and observe July 10 anganwadi demands day, as ‘Black day’. It has been decided to reach each and every anganwadi worker and helper and educate them on the ICDS Mission, in the first phase. With a membership above five lakh, ten lakh leaflets on the ICDS Mission were distributed all over the country in vernacular languages among the anganwadi workers and helpers. A booklet on the details of the ICDS Mission was prepared and is being circulated among the activists at the grass root level. Fifty thousand booklets in Hindi are already distributed in the Hindi speaking states.

 

TREMENDOUS

RESPONSE

Efforts are made by the government to disrupt the struggle in many ways. The WCD minister, on July 4, 2013, repeated the announcement of the increase which was meant for only anganwadi workers of mini anganwadi centres and was already announced as early in November 2012. This appeared as an increase to all workers and was meant to confuse the workers and the public. This is also against the demand of the mini anganwadi workers who will now get rupees 750 less than the regular worker, that too with effect from April 1, 2013, in place of April 1, 2011.

 

In many parts of the country, the administration and the police tried to sabotage the programme by issuing memos to anganwadi workers and helpers, denying permission etc.

 

But, the campaign and the struggle got tremendous response from the anganwadi workers and helpers. The ‘Black Day’ was observed in Andhra Pradesh, Assam, Bihar, Chhattisgarh, Delhi, Gujarat, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Jharkhand, Jammu&Kashmir, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Punjab, Rajasthan, Tamilnadu, Tripura and Uttar Pradesh. The programme could not be held in Uttarakhand due to the relief work, in West Bengal due to the panchayat elections and due to Rath Yatra in Odisha. Due to festival in some districts, it was observed on July 10-12 in Gujarat. The programme is postponed to July 19 in Kerala, because of a hartal by the Left Front on that day in the state. The ‘Black Day’ was observed at project level in HP and at state level in MP. In Andhra Pradesh the union went on three days strike from July 8-10. According to the reports received till now, on July 10, in total, more than two lakh seven thousand anganwadi workers came out on the streets on that day in more than 210 districts in 18 states.

 

In many places, there was police lathicharge. In Andhra Pradesh, nearly five thousand were arrested in different districts. In Karnataka, in three places there was lathi charge and arrest. In Punjab at two places, in Chattisgarh, in Haryana etc arrest and lathicharge was reported.

 

Tapan Sen, general secretary, CITU inaugurated the dharna held at ITO, New Delhi. A R Sindhu, secretary CITU and general secretary AIFAWH, K Hemalata, secretary and Ranjana Nirula, treasurer CITU addressed the gathering. Kamala, state general secretary of Anganwadi Workers and Helpers Union, M L Malkotia, general secretary, state CITU also addressed.

 

AIFAWH decided to intensify the struggle to save ICDS along with the mass organisations of the beneficiaries like AIDWA, AIAWU and AIKS.